Aerial view of a working limestone quarry
Deal Diligence · Buy-Side
Operational due diligence: will the earnings still be yours?
A Quality of Earnings proves what the business earned. It does not tell you who produced it, whether that person is leaving, or what leaves with him. This engagement tests the seats the earnings actually run through, the customers behind the numbers, and whether either survives a change of owner. Buy-side only, led by an operator, and built for deals of roughly $500K to $5M of EBITDA.
Hoosier Supply Co. · Illustrative
Three findings that do not appear in the financial statements.
42%
Of revenue sits behind a relationship the owner holds himself
The customer named him as first call without being asked, and the sales system carries him as representative of record. There is no account manager on the account and no system in which one could exist. Nine years of purchase orders, with no term and no assignment language.
1.8 of 5
Leadership bench, the lowest of the five dimensions scored
The binding constraint is not the one most buyers expect. Owner dependence is the symptom, and the reason it cannot be fixed on a normal timetable is that there is no second seat to move the work into. Neither of the two people a buyer has to keep is under an employment agreement.
$77K
A year of gross profit inside one price file nobody reset
Product cost moved from 63.5% to 64.2% of revenue in FY2024. The price file was last recalibrated in FY2023 and nobody re-priced the step, so roughly $2.9M of revenue is quoted without a framework. The statements show the margin slipping. Only the quoting process says why.

Where the documents stop

Both reads, one boundary

A Quality of Earnings can prove
  • What the business earned, tied to the bank
  • Every add-back, tested against the three gates
  • The owner’s personal spending, stripped out
  • An operator’s read of the files, and a forward verdict, at no charge
Only interviews and calls can prove
  • Who the customer actually calls
  • What the second in command is allowed to decide
  • Whether a competent stranger could run it on Monday
  • Which revenue actually leaves if the owner does
  • Whether the position held, or the margin was a moment
  • What has to be true in the first hundred days

The free read stops at the boundary; this engagement is what sits on the other side of it. If you do not buy it, the included read still stands and the Quality of Earnings report is complete without it.

The handoff
A buyer cannot run these two tests himself without tipping off the seller.
You can read every document in the data room and still not know who the customer calls when a job sits three weeks. Ownership of a relationship is not a recorded fact. It lives in a mobile phone, a twenty-year habit, and a name that never appears on an invoice. There are two ways to find it out and neither is available to you. You cannot put the owner and his office manager in separate rooms and ask each what she is allowed to decide. You cannot call four of the target’s customers, because a leaked process costs the seller his business. We can do both, through the seller, with written consent, and Jared Luegers makes those calls himself.
Two managers in high-visibility vests walking the floor of a modern manufacturing plant.
Owner dependence
Three of the five seats that produce the earnings are held by the owner, and not one has a successor.
A seat is defined by the outcome it owns, not by the title on the payroll register. On the sample business the owner holds the buying relationship, twenty-eight years in it, and purchasing runs through him with no documented procedure. None of that is in the data room. It comes from his calendar, from where the approvals actually route, and from asking his office manager, in a separate room, what she is allowed to decide.

Where the authority actually sits

The five critical seats, and where the decisions land

Revenue and key accounts28 years in the seatPricing and estimating$2.9M a year priced by handOffice and operationsOffice manager, 6 yearsPurchasing and vendorsSole approver over $25KBooks and close20 hours a weekThe owner3 of 5 seatsnone with a successorThe business2 of 5 seatsone of them half a person

The owner 3 of 5 seats

  • Revenue and key accounts28 years in the seat
  • Pricing and estimating$2.9M a year priced by hand
  • Purchasing and vendorsSole approver over $25K

None with a named successor.

The business 2 of 5 seats

  • Office and operationsOffice manager, 6 years
  • Books and close20 hours a week, half a seat
His calendar
61%

Of scheduled time over the trailing 90 days sat in customer, pricing or vendor meetings.

The approvals
11 of 14

Recurring approvals route to him, including every discount above 8% and every purchase order above $25K. Neither limit is written down.

A Quality of Earnings cannot produce this picture.

It comes from the calendar, the approval routing and separated interviews, not from documents.

A seat counts as owner-held only where it meets at least two of three tests. Illustrative; Hoosier Supply Co. is fictional.

How the verdict is reached

Two gates, three outcomes

Does it runwithout him?YESNOCan the gap be writteninto an agreement?YESNOTransferableNegotiate on the numbers.Transferable, with conditionsWrite the conditions in.Not transferable as structuredA different deal, not no deal.

Gate one. Does it run without him?

If yes

Transferable

An ordinary transition carries it. Negotiate on the numbers.

Gate two. Can the gap be written into an agreement?

If yes

Transferable, with conditions

A seat under agreement, a covenant, a stay instrument, an escrow sized to one account.

Not transferable as structured

A different deal, not no deal: a different structure, price, or set of conditions before close.

We name where the risk sits; what you pay is yours to decide. The verdict sets no price and puts no value or multiple on the business in writing.

How it ends
Two gates decide it, and each outcome changes a different part of the deal.
Transferable means an ordinary transition carries it, and price stays a negotiation about the numbers. Transferable with conditions means it carries on terms your lawyer can write: a seat under agreement before close, a covenant where there is none today, an escrow sized to one account rather than to a general worry. Not transferable as structured means what produces the earnings does not survive the seller’s departure on any timetable we can name. That is a different deal, not no deal.
Scope
Eight workstreams, scoped in writing before anything starts.

The eight workstreams

Fixed in the engagement letter

01Owner dependency

Does the business run, or does he?

The five seats mapped, with successor status on each.

02Revenue at risk

Which revenue actually leaves if he does?

Three scenarios, each with the EBITDA effect.

03Bench depth

Is the second in command ready, or only titled?

A departure-impact rating per seat.

04Systems and cadence

Could a competent stranger run this next Monday?

Processes scored, and the gaps that produce financial symptoms.

05Revenue durability

Was the pricing power real, or was the margin a moment?

Whether the earnings base repeats, and where margin is recoverable.

06Reference calls

Who do they call when something goes wrong?

Verbatim answers by account, buy-side only, through the seller.

07Market position

Does the position hold?

A bounded desk read against a named competitor set.

08Forward plan

What has to be true in the first hundred days?

A dated plan, each action with an owner and a measure.

The forward plan
Everything left of the close is a condition you can still get. Everything right of it is a cost.
Twelve actions across four bands. An action without an owner and a measure is a wish, and a plan of wishes is how the first year gets away from a new owner.

The first hundred days

Twelve actions, each with a named owner and a measure

Before close

Conditions, not intentions

Owner-held seats under agreement; a covenant where none exists.

Days 1–30

Relationships and the pricing floor

The top account handed over with the seller in the room.

Days 31–60

Visibility, then the vendor seat

Replenishment on a rule; the change-of-control clause reviewed.

Days 61–100

Make the pricing seat permanent

The estimating seat backed; purchasing documented.

The wire clears
Day 30
Day 60
Day 100

The binding constraint here is bench, not the owner. Illustrative; Hoosier Supply Co. is fictional.

If you want the plan run rather than written, that is the embedded CFO and operating partner engagement.
See the actual work
You can read a whole operational review before you decide.
The readout excerpt
The five seats, the scorecard and the verdict page from a full operational review. Three pages is enough to tell whether a firm can actually do this, which is the only reason to offer them.
Ask on the call or by email. It comes back the same day, with no form to fill in.
First page of the LIMESTONE sample Quality of Earnings report, Light scope
The full sample report
Fourteen pages: the findings register, the reference-call verbatims, the revenue-at-risk scenarios and the hundred-day plan. Hoosier Supply Co. is fictional and every page says so. It includes the green findings as carefully as the red: a 96.4% fill rate named unprompted by five of six customers, set against three material service failures in 24 months.
Sent. It is on its way from Ryan Anoskey and usually arrives within a minute. If it does not, check your spam folder.
That did not send. Try once more, and if it still will not go through, contact us and we will send it across.
Your address is used for the report and a single follow-up. Nothing else.

Questions We Get

What buyers ask before they commit.

If yours is not here, ask it on the call.

What does operational due diligence cover that a Quality of Earnings does not?

A Quality of Earnings answers what the business earned and proves it to the bank statement. This answers whether that continues under a new owner. It is six things a financial scope does not include: customer and vendor reference calls, separate interviews with the management team, a systems inventory, a documentation review tested against whether a competent stranger could execute the work, a quantified revenue-at-risk figure, and a bounded market study. Our own Quality of Earnings includes an operator’s read at no charge, and that read stops at the documents.

Do you talk to the customers?

On buy-side engagements, yes, and only through the seller with written consent. We never cold-call a target’s customers. The seller arranges the introductions and the partner who signs the work makes the calls. If the seller declines an account we record the refusal, because a refusal is itself a finding. We ask one question first, every time: who do you call when something goes wrong.

How long does it take, and how many of these do you run at once?

15 to 20 business days, and the clock starts when the last critical item on the request list arrives rather than at signing. We run two at a time, which is a published limit rather than a secret one. If the window is too short to do the work properly we will turn it down.

Someone else did the Quality of Earnings. Can you still do this?

Yes, and it is a common way to buy it. We are not re-auditing their numbers and we are not grading their work. We read their report as a request list and a starting position, and it feeds our revenue-at-risk work, which shortens ours. We do not work both sides of the same transaction.

What does the verdict actually mean for my price and structure?

Transferable leaves the negotiation on the numbers. Transferable with conditions is the useful verdict, because the conditions are things your lawyer can write. Not transferable as structured means the deal in front of you is not the deal that survives, which is a structure and price conversation rather than an automatic walk-away. We name where the risk sits; what you pay is yours to decide.

I am buying with an SBA loan. Do I need this?

The SOP does not require it. On a 7(a) acquisition at $3 million or more the lender must order a Quality of Earnings, that report is prepared for the lender rather than for you, and the mandate is financial. Nothing in SOP 50 10 8.1 asks anyone to test whether the operation transfers. Two other rules sharpen the gap: the seller cannot stay on as an officer, director, stockholder or employee, and consulting with him is capped at 24 months. The transition you are counting on has a legal ceiling, and you are guaranteeing the debt personally.

What is this engagement not?

It is not a Quality of Earnings; it uses one, and on a bundled engagement we run both. It is not a valuation: we are not appraisers, and no multiple or value figure appears in anything we issue. It is not an audit, a review or an attest engagement. It is not a management assessment for hiring; we test whether the seats are covered through a change of owner. And it is not a promise the earnings will hold.

get started

Find out whether the earnings transfer while you can still price it.
Three ways to buy it: standalone, bundled onto a LIMESTONE review, or run on your own business before a buyer runs it on you. Bring us the deal on your desk. A short call, then one fixed fee in writing, usually inside a business day. If this deal does not need a full operational review, that is what you will hear. Indiana-rooted. Serving buyers and owners nationwide.

Jared Luegers, CFA · Founder and Managing Partner · jared@limestonesp.com

Ryan Anoskey, CPA · Partner · ryan.anoskey@limestonesp.com